Vest CPA
← All postsBothSep 18, 20267 min readDrew Duskin, CPA

What is a 409A valuation?

Why we wrote this

We wrote this partly so founders and startup employees searching for "409A" would find us. We'll be upfront about that. We'll also be upfront that this is a service we don't sell. A 409A touches your option grants, your employees' taxes and your books, and that's where we come in. So here's the plain version.

What is a 409A valuation?

A 409A valuation is an estimate of what one share of your company's common stock is worth. Public companies have a stock price every day. Private startups don't, so they need a defensible number for the day they grant options.

The name comes from Section 409A of the tax code, the rule that covers deferred compensation. Stock options can fall under that rule. Under the Treasury regulations, an option is exempt from 409A only if its exercise price can never be less than the fair market value of the underlying stock on the grant date. So the 409A value sets the floor for your strike price.

Put simply:

  • The valuation tells you what your common stock is worth today.
  • The strike price on any new option has to be at least that number.
  • Getting it right keeps your employees out of a nasty tax problem.

Why does a startup need a 409A valuation?

A startup needs a 409A valuation because it wants to grant stock options without creating a tax problem for the people who receive them. Once you start building an option pool and making offers with equity, you need a defensible fair market value for every grant date.

For most startups, this first comes up with the first option grant. You hire your first or second employee, you want to offer options, and now you need a number for the strike price. That's normal. It's part of moving from "founders only" to "a team with equity."

What happens if options are granted below fair market value?

If an option is granted below fair market value and doesn't otherwise comply with Section 409A, the employee pays the price, not the company. Under Section 409A of the tax code, the option holder faces:

  • income on the deferred amount once the option vests
  • an extra 20% tax on that amount
  • premium interest at the IRS underpayment rate plus 1 percentage point

The company isn't off the hook either. It has withholding and reporting exposure. And it's your team who gets the surprise bill, which is a terrible way to treat people you hired with the promise of equity.

Who does 409A valuations?

Independent valuation firms and equity platforms do 409A valuations, including Carta. We don't. That's on purpose. A 409A is a valuation job, and it belongs with a valuation provider.

Here's what we do instead. Our tech clients use Carta and give us access to their cap table. We read it, and we make sure the tax and accounting side matches what's actually happened with your equity. More on that below.

What are the 409A safe harbor methods?

The regulations list three methods that are presumed reasonable. Under the Treasury regulations, the IRS can only overturn a value set this way by showing the method, or how it was applied, was "grossly unreasonable."

  • Independent appraisal. It has to meet the appraisal standards in the regs and be dated no more than 12 months before the grant.
  • Formula price. A formula used consistently under a nonlapse restriction.
  • Illiquid start-up method. A written, good-faith report by someone with significant knowledge and experience, generally at least 5 years in business valuation or appraisal. It's only available if the company has no business it has run for 10 years or more, and only if it doesn't reasonably expect a change of control within 90 days or an IPO within 180 days.

Your valuation provider picks the method. What you want to know as a founder is that a safe harbor valuation gives your grants a strong footing.

How long is a 409A valuation good for?

A 409A valuation is generally good for up to 12 months, or until something material changes, whichever comes first. The regulations say a prior valuation isn't reasonable to use if it's more than 12 months old. It also isn't reasonable if it fails to reflect later information that may materially affect the value.

Events that usually mean you need a new one:

  • a priced funding round
  • an acquisition offer
  • a major change in the business

The trap is thinking a 409A is good for 12 months no matter what. It isn't. If you close a priced round in month four and keep granting options at the old number, you may be granting below fair market value. Talk to your valuation provider before your next grant.

What does a 409A mean if you're an employee with options?

If you're an employee with options, the 409A is why your strike price is what it is. Your strike price was set at or above the company's 409A value on your grant date. That number shows up in your taxes later.

  • Early exercise and the 83(b). If you exercise options before they vest, you get unvested stock, and you have 30 days from that exercise to file an 83(b) election. For NSOs, the election taxes the spread at exercise, which is often zero when the strike equals fair market value. For ISOs, the 83(b) counts only for AMT, so don't count on it to start your capital gains clock.
  • ISOs and AMT. According to IRS Publication 525, the spread at exercise (the stock's fair market value minus your option price) is an AMT adjustment if you hold the shares past year-end. This is where planning pays off. We cover it in the ISO and AMT trap.
  • QSBS. The QSBS clock starts when you exercise and own stock, not when you get the option. Holding an option isn't holding stock.

If you're sitting on options and trying to decide when to exercise, that's what our equity compensation tax planning work is for.

Where does Vest fit in?

We fit in on the tax and accounting side of everything the cap table touches. We don't run your cap table (that's Carta) and we don't value your stock (that's your valuation provider). We read the cap table so these stay aligned:

  • Your books. SAFEs, convertible notes, warrants and stock comp expense need to be recorded correctly. Our startup accounting team handles this.
  • 83(b) elections. We can file them for clients, online through the IRS or on paper.
  • Form 3921. Your company has to issue one for each ISO exercise by January 31 of the following year.
  • QSBS records. Who got stock, when, and for what. You'll want this clean long before an exit. See our QSBS and exit planning work.
  • Delaware franchise tax. The method that usually lowers the bill needs your issued shares and gross assets. The cap table has the first number.
  • Your employees' planning. When someone wants to exercise ISOs, we run the AMT projections.

What's the most common mistake we see?

The most common mistake we see isn't the valuation itself. It's the books and tax side falling behind the equity. A founder signs a SAFE, grants the first options, maybe early-exercises some founder shares, and the bookkeeping never catches up.

We see this a lot with founders who started with a budget bookkeeper. A SAFE comes in, and the bookkeeper doesn't know how to book it. The founder feels that gap and starts looking for someone who knows startup equity. That's often when they find us.

The fix isn't complicated. Someone has to read the cap table on a regular schedule and make sure the books, the filings and the tax planning match it. When that happens, diligence later is a much easier conversation.

Quick numbers to know

  • 12 months: the longest a 409A is generally used, sooner if something material happens
  • 20%: the extra tax on an option holder when a discounted option fails 409A
  • 1 percentage point: added to the IRS underpayment rate for the premium interest
  • 5 years: experience generally needed for the illiquid start-up method
  • 10 years: a company that has run a business this long can't use the illiquid start-up method
  • 90 days / 180 days: expected change of control or IPO windows that rule out the illiquid start-up method
  • 30 days: to file an 83(b) after an early exercise
  • January 31: Form 3921 due to employees for the prior year's ISO exercises

Granting equity soon? Let's make sure the tax side keeps up

If you're about to grant your first options, or you just closed a round and you're not sure your books reflect it, our team, led by Drew, can help. Drew spent the first eight years of his career in the Bay Area working with VC-backed startups, and reading cap tables is a normal part of our week.

We work with founders and tech employees in Seattle and Bellevue, the Bay Area, Austin and across the US. Start with our page for founders and startups, or apply to work with us. For a checklist of what to set up in your first 60 days, grab the 83(b) and QSBS Founder Checklist.

*This article is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Rules change, and the details matter. Talk to a CPA before you act.*

Related serviceFor Founders and Startups→
Sources (5)
  1. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, Treas. Reg. 1.409A-1: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.409A-1
  2. Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 409A: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/409A
  3. Carta, "409A valuation": https://carta.com/learn/startups/equity-management/409a-valuation/
  4. IRS, Publication 525: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p525
  5. Not linked in the body but used for facts: IRS Form 15620 and instructions (83(b) and early exercise): https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f15620.pdf . Morrison & Foerster on early-exercised ISOs: https://www.mofo.com/pdf/resources/insights/260116-early-exercise-of-isos-why-it-doesn-t-work . Bernstein on when the QSBS clock starts: https://www.bernstein.com/our-insights/insights/2026/articles/answering-your-top-10-qsbs-questions.html . IRS Topic 427 (Form 3921): https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc427 . Delaware Division of Corporations franchise tax calculator: https://corp.delaware.gov/frtaxcalc/

This article is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Rules change, and the details matter. Talk to a CPA before you act.

Step 01 · Apply

Ready when you are.

Apply in about 5 minutes. We reply by email, and if it looks like a fit, we book a free 15-minute call.